By the time Linda Ronstadt walked into the Sound Factory in Los Angeles in the summer of 1974, she had been at this for seven years — seven years of strong taste, wrong luck, and a voice that nobody quite knew what to do with. She had three solo albums for Capitol Records, each one earnest and each one quietly ignored.
She was twenty-eight years old, recently arrived in the Laurel Canyon orbit of the Eagles and Jackson Browne, and widely regarded as one of the best singers alive by people who couldn’t find her records in a store. Then came Heart Like a Wheel. Then came “You’re No Good.” Then everything changed, all at once, the way certain things do — not gradually but suddenly, like a door opening that you didn’t know was there.
>>> Scroll down for the video <<<
“You’re No Good” was not a new song when Ronstadt recorded it. Clint Ballard Jr. had written it, and Dee Dee Warwick — Dionne’s sister — first cut it in 1963, produced by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, though it barely dented the chart. Betty Everett brought it to number 51 that same year. The Swinging Blue Jeans, a British Merseybeat act, took it to number 3 in the UK in 1964. The song had lived several lives already. It had been stomped, crooned, and swagger-stepped. It had been passed around like a good instrument that nobody had quite figured out the tuning on.
Bassist Kenny Edwards — an old friend from the Stone Poneys days who had rejoined her band — suggested the song during rehearsals for a 1973 Neil Young tour. Ronstadt had been closing her sets with it. “I’m a ballad singer,” she later said, “and in a lot of the venues we were playing, the air conditioning was louder than we were. So we had to have a couple of uptempo songs to open and close with. And that was a really good closer.” Useful, then. A tool for the live room. Not yet what it would become.
The recording almost didn’t work. The first session on July 1, 1974 brought in R&B players and pushed the song hard — too fast, too frictionless. Ronstadt vetoed it. “It was just the wrong groove for me,” she remembered. “I don’t think I knew how to phrase around them.” A few days later they tried again, stripping the arrangement down. Ed Black started playing a rhythm riff on a Les Paul.
Kenny Edwards echoed it in octaves on bass. Andrew Gold — a multi-instrumentalist who would soon have his own career — built up a sparse drum track around them. Ronstadt sang to that, live in the room. The groove was slower. Sweatier. It had space inside it that her voice could move through instead of fight against.
Andrew Gold also played the guitar solo — a part that was accidentally erased from the tape during playback, then reconstructed from memory in the middle of the night. Ronstadt and comedian Albert Brooks came in the next day to hear the result. She almost rejected it again; the middle section sounded, she thought, too much like the Beatles. Gold had in fact been aiming for exactly that. She eventually came around. A string arrangement by Gregory Rose was added later at AIR Studios in London. The final mix ended with a long sustained note on the strings, the engineer slowly riding the faders up as the song exhaled.
What Ronstadt did to this song is easier to feel than to explain. The earlier versions all carry a specific emotional temperature: feminine frustration, the bright sting of a woman calling out a man who wasted her time. They are songs of relief more than fury. Dee Dee Warwick sounds like she means every word; Betty Everett sounds like she almost enjoyed saying it. The Swinging Blue Jeans, having flipped the gender, sound like boys who read it in a textbook. But Ronstadt’s version sits somewhere else entirely.
There’s something in her reading that is less about triumph and more about weight. When she sings feeling better now that I’m through with you, the line doesn’t quite land as a declaration. It lands as something she is still trying to convince herself of. That tension — between the words of a woman who has moved on and the voice of a woman who is still moving — is what the recording holds, and holds, and holds.
Her voice in 1974 was something you’d point to if you needed to explain what “command” means in a singer. Not loudness — she was not a shouter. Not range — though hers was formidable. Command is something quieter than both: it’s the sense that the singer knows exactly where the center of the room is, and is already standing in it. You feel that here from the first line. She sounds like she could sing this song for three hours and never tire of it, never lose the thread, never let the heat drop below a certain temperature. That ease is the most difficult thing to achieve and the most impossible to fake.
Capitol Records wasn’t sure whether to release “You’re No Good” or another track, “When Will I Be Loved,” as the lead single from Heart Like a Wheel. They decided only a week after the album’s November 1974 release, and even then somewhat hesitantly. By February 15, 1975, it was the number-one song in the United States — Ronstadt’s only chart-topper in a career that would be stuffed with hits. The album went double Platinum.
It was nominated for the Grammy Award for Album of the Year. The Library of Congress inducted it into the National Recording Registry in 2013. The woman who had spent seven years making albums nobody bought had, in the span of a single, become one of the biggest stars in the country.
Ronstadt herself was characteristically unromantic about all of this. “It’s a live vocal, and it’s a terrible vocal,” she said years later of her performance on the record. This is the kind of thing that great artists say, and it is also the kind of thing that is plainly, obviously wrong. What she heard as imperfection — the slight roughness, the places where the voice catches rather than glides — is exactly what makes the recording feel inhabited rather than executed. You can hear a person in it. You can hear someone who has been through something, is still inside something, and chose this song as the most honest way to say so.
There is a moment near the end, before the strings swell to their long final note, where she sings the title phrase one last time and you can feel the whole room pressing in around her. She sounds utterly certain and utterly tired at the same time, which is the most honest combination of feelings a breakup song can hold. The song ends. The strings breathe out. And you sit there thinking: yes. That’s exactly it. That’s exactly what it felt like.
Hey readers! Chip Holland here, and I’m a Manager of this website. My passion for writing about it only matches my passion for BBQ. Follow my blog for mouth-watering recipes, tips, and tricks for the perfect smoke, grill, and BBQ. I’m sure you won’t be disappointed!